Tail Coverage Cost Estimator
This tool helps you estimate the cost of "Tail Coverage" (officially known as an Extended Reporting Period or ERP) for a claims-made insurance policy when it expires or is replaced. Tail coverage is crucial for claims-made policies to cover claims reported *after* the policy ends, but which occurred *during* the policy period.
Enter the amount of your **Last Annual Premium** for the claims-made policy that is ending or being replaced, and select the **Desired Duration** for the tail coverage. The tool will provide an estimated cost.
Enter Policy Details
Understanding Tail Coverage (Extended Reporting Period)
What is Tail Coverage?
Tail coverage, or an Extended Reporting Period (ERP), is an endorsement or separate policy purchased when a "claims-made" insurance policy is terminated (either due to changing insurers, changing policy types, retirement, etc.). A claims-made policy only covers claims that are *reported* while the policy is active. Without tail coverage, once the policy ends, you have no coverage for claims that might arise later, even if the incident occurred while the policy *was* active. Tail coverage extends the time you have to report claims for incidents that happened during the expired claims-made policy period.
How Tail Coverage Cost is Calculated (Basis)
The cost of tail coverage is typically a one-time, upfront premium based on a percentage multiplier applied to the **last annual premium** you paid for the expiring claims-made policy. This percentage varies significantly based on the duration of the tail coverage you purchase. Longer durations (like "Unlimited") have higher multipliers than shorter durations (like 1 or 2 years).
Typical Cost Multipliers (Estimates)
While costs vary, common multipliers of the last annual premium are:
- 1 Year Tail: ~100% - 150%
- 2 Year Tail: ~150% - 200%
- 3 Year Tail: ~175% - 250%
- 5 Year Tail: ~200% - 300%
- Unlimited Tail: ~200% - 400%+
This calculator uses simplified, fixed multipliers for estimation purposes. Consult with your insurance broker for an exact quote.
Calculator's Estimated Multipliers:
- 1 Year: 1.5x
- 2 Years: 2.0x
- 3 Years: 2.5x
- 5 Years: 2.75x
- Unlimited: 3.0x
Why is it Important?
Without tail coverage, you could face significant financial risk if a past client or patient files a claim against you after your claims-made policy is no longer in effect. It's a critical consideration when transitioning away from a claims-made policy.
Tail Coverage Cost Examples
Here are examples of how the estimated cost is calculated based on different last annual premiums and durations using this tool's multipliers:
Example 1: Standard Retirement (Unlimited Tail)
Scenario: A professional is retiring and needs unlimited tail coverage.
1. Known Values: Last Annual Premium = $10,000, Desired Duration = Unlimited.
2. Tool Multiplier: Unlimited Tail = 3.0x.
3. Calculation: Estimated Cost = $10,000 * 3.0 = $30,000.
4. Result: Estimated Tail Cost = $30,000.
Conclusion: Purchasing unlimited tail based on a $10k last premium is estimated to cost around $30k.
Example 2: Switching Insurers (1 Year Tail, if needed)
Scenario: A business owner is switching claims-made insurers and the new policy doesn't offer prior acts coverage back to the original retroactive date (less common, but requires tail). They only need a 1-year tail to bridge a gap.
1. Known Values: Last Annual Premium = $5,000, Desired Duration = 1 Year.
2. Tool Multiplier: 1 Year Tail = 1.5x.
3. Calculation: Estimated Cost = $5,000 * 1.5 = $7,500.
4. Result: Estimated Tail Cost = $7,500.
Conclusion: A 1-year tail based on a $5k last premium is estimated to cost around $7.5k.
Example 3: Physician Changing Practice (3 Year Tail)
Scenario: A physician is closing their practice and joining a large hospital group whose policy provides "prior acts" coverage. However, their previous contract requires them to maintain a 3-year tail for their old practice's activities.
1. Known Values: Last Annual Premium = $25,000, Desired Duration = 3 Years.
2. Tool Multiplier: 3 Years Tail = 2.5x.
3. Calculation: Estimated Cost = $25,000 * 2.5 = $62,500.
4. Result: Estimated Tail Cost = $62,500.
Conclusion: A 3-year tail based on a $25k last premium is estimated to cost around $62.5k.
Example 4: Architect Closing Firm (5 Year Tail)
Scenario: An architect is closing their small firm and needs tail coverage for potential future claims related to past projects. They opt for a 5-year tail.
1. Known Values: Last Annual Premium = $7,500, Desired Duration = 5 Years.
2. Tool Multiplier: 5 Years Tail = 2.75x.
3. Calculation: Estimated Cost = $7,500 * 2.75 = $20,625.
4. Result: Estimated Tail Cost = $20,625.
Conclusion: A 5-year tail based on a $7.5k last premium is estimated to cost around $20.6k.
Example 5: Dentist Retiring (Unlimited Tail)
Scenario: A dentist is retiring after a long career and needs "forever" tail coverage.
1. Known Values: Last Annual Premium = $18,000, Desired Duration = Unlimited.
2. Tool Multiplier: Unlimited Tail = 3.0x.
3. Calculation: Estimated Cost = $18,000 * 3.0 = $54,000.
4. Result: Estimated Tail Cost = $54,000.
Conclusion: An unlimited tail based on an $18k last premium is estimated to cost around $54k.
Example 6: Therapist Taking Leave (2 Year Tail)
Scenario: A therapist is taking a 2-year leave of absence and her current claims-made policy will lapse. She needs a 2-year tail to cover her during this period.
1. Known Values: Last Annual Premium = $2,500, Desired Duration = 2 Years.
2. Tool Multiplier: 2 Years Tail = 2.0x.
3. Calculation: Estimated Cost = $2,500 * 2.0 = $5,000.
4. Result: Estimated Tail Cost = $5,000.
Conclusion: A 2-year tail based on a $2.5k last premium is estimated to cost around $5k.
Example 7: Consulting Firm Closing (Unlimited Tail)
Scenario: A small consulting firm is dissolving, and the partners want to ensure coverage for any claims arising from past work indefinitely.
1. Known Values: Last Annual Premium = $15,000, Desired Duration = Unlimited.
2. Tool Multiplier: Unlimited Tail = 3.0x.
3. Calculation: Estimated Cost = $15,000 * 3.0 = $45,000.
4. Result: Estimated Tail Cost = $45,000.
Conclusion: An unlimited tail based on a $15k last premium is estimated to cost around $45k.
Example 8: Real Estate Agent Retiring (5 Year Tail)
Scenario: A real estate agent is retiring and decides a 5-year tail is sufficient based on advice regarding the statute of limitations in their area.
1. Known Values: Last Annual Premium = $3,000, Desired Duration = 5 Years.
2. Tool Multiplier: 5 Years Tail = 2.75x.
3. Calculation: Estimated Cost = $3,000 * 2.75 = $8,250.
4. Result: Estimated Tail Cost = $8,250.
Conclusion: A 5-year tail based on a $3k last premium is estimated to cost around $8.25k.
Example 9: IT Contractor Taking Hiatus (1 Year Tail)
Scenario: An IT contractor is taking a year off from work and lets their claims-made policy expire. They purchase a 1-year tail just in case something arises during that year.
1. Known Values: Last Annual Premium = $2,000, Desired Duration = 1 Year.
2. Tool Multiplier: 1 Year Tail = 1.5x.
3. Calculation: Estimated Cost = $2,000 * 1.5 = $3,000.
4. Result: Estimated Tail Cost = $3,000.
Conclusion: A 1-year tail based on a $2k last premium is estimated to cost around $3k.
Example 10: Agency Merging (Unlimited Tail)
Scenario: A small marketing agency with a claims-made E&O policy is merging into a larger company, and the larger company's policy requires the merging agency to purchase an unlimited tail for its past liabilities.
1. Known Values: Last Annual Premium = $12,000, Desired Duration = Unlimited.
2. Tool Multiplier: Unlimited Tail = 3.0x.
3. Calculation: Estimated Cost = $12,000 * 3.0 = $36,000.
4. Result: Estimated Tail Cost = $36,000.
Conclusion: An unlimited tail based on a $12k last premium is estimated to cost around $36k.
Frequently Asked Questions about Tail Coverage
1. What type of insurance policy requires tail coverage?
Tail coverage is typically needed for "claims-made" insurance policies (like Professional Liability/Errors & Omissions or Directors & Officers) when they end. Occurrence policies do *not* require tail coverage.
2. Why is tail coverage necessary for claims-made policies?
Claims-made policies only cover claims that are *reported* while the policy is active. If an incident happens during the policy period but a claim isn't reported until *after* the policy ends, there would be no coverage without tail coverage.
3. How is the cost of tail coverage determined?
The cost is usually a one-time premium calculated as a multiplier (percentage) of the last annual premium paid for the expiring policy. The multiplier depends primarily on the duration of the tail coverage purchased.
4. What is a typical cost range for tail coverage?
It varies widely but commonly ranges from 100% to 400% or more of the last annual premium, depending on the duration (e.g., 1 year vs. unlimited) and other risk factors.
5. Is the calculator's estimate exact?
No, the calculator provides an *estimate* based on typical multipliers. The actual cost will be determined by your specific insurance provider based on factors like your profession, claims history, state regulations, and the specific insurer's pricing models.
6. When should I buy tail coverage?
You typically purchase tail coverage when your claims-made policy is ending and you won't have continuous "prior acts" coverage under a new policy. This happens when you retire, switch to an occurrence policy, change professions, or cease business operations.
7. What is "Prior Acts" coverage (or Retroactive Coverage)?
This is coverage provided by a *new* claims-made policy that covers claims for incidents that occurred *before* the new policy started, going back to the retroactive date. If your new policy has a retroactive date that matches or precedes your old policy's end date, you may not need tail coverage from the old insurer.
8. Is tail coverage a one-time cost?
Yes, tail coverage is typically purchased as a single, non-refundable premium for the chosen duration (e.g., 1 year, 3 years, unlimited). Once paid, the coverage is in place for that duration without further annual premiums.
9. Can I negotiate the cost of tail coverage?
The cost is usually fixed by the insurer based on their filings and rating structure. While you can't typically negotiate the multiplier directly, getting quotes from different brokers who work with various insurers might yield different prices.
10. Is unlimited tail coverage always the best option?
Unlimited tail provides the longest peace of mind, covering claims indefinitely into the future. However, it is also the most expensive. Shorter tails might be sufficient depending on the statute of limitations for claims related to your profession in your jurisdiction, but unlimited is often recommended if feasible, especially upon retirement.
